[Snarf]

Okay, well i just finished it with a friend at night. volume up but no headphones. Its kinda scary i guess but the more you play it the less scary it gets. no replay value at all, except for the custom stories.

That's basic psychology. The more you play a game the more familiarized you will get. The more familiarized you are with something that is supposed to be frightening the less frightening it is. The unknown will always be more frightening than the known. And what your imagination makes things out to be is going to be a lot scarier than anything a programmer could make. Unless they were handing out nude pictures of Rosie O'Donnell or something.
It's still the best true horror game we have gotten in a VERY long time.