[OmegaZero_Alpha]

You seriously still fucking care?

I have more of a problem with him just repeating the same fallacious bullshit.

Like the part where you stated the other side can't do it, when in fact they can? Or are you not counting that in your "fallacious bullshit" category?

The other side can do it, but from what I have seen it isn't nearly as easy to hit people on the other battlements, and is easier to counter. (landing a pipebomb anywhere on that roof will have it roll down on them, whereas you have to actually get it through that window to hit them). And I am leaving myself open for correction on this one because I've never sat on the battlements for long enough to actually check this out. (except when I'm playing sniper, or the significantly more fun WRANGLER SNIPER, in which case it has no bearing on this.)

And for a minor correction the term "Fallacious" implies a logic error, not a factual integrity error, and the fallacies I am referring to are the ones that imply that this is still not open to individual interpretation.

Everything that can be said here has already been said here and the only thing that will differ is the meaningless analogies and personal anecdotes which don't have any real impact on the matter at hand.

So I think that you should just let this die until an actual developer at Valve decides to make a judgment on it.