[djdwosk97]

We cannot make them both public and not indexable by bots.

I'm pretty sure there is a way. The Great Below on the Backpack.tf forums aren't indexed by google, yet there still publicly viewable (although, now that i think about it you might need to be signed in order to view that thread).

Edit: Yep, requires a log-in, which isn't unreasonable--requiring people to log-in to view inactive threads.